Even in a Pandemic, Grades Matter!

By -
This article was written originally for MultiBriefs Education.
Fellow school principals, I’m calling on each of you to take action with grading reform in your schools. We need grades that matter, and we need them now!
Last month, I participated in a Zoom call with fifty fellow high school principals from my state as we all discussed the pros and cons of reverting to a pass/fail grading system to close out the 2019-2020 school year. The rationale for moving to such a system now was born from the growing concern among educators that current grades and grading practices in remote learning systems are not an accurate measure of student learning and would likely penalize and hurt students if such drastic measures were not put into place. Interestingly, on the call that day there emerged two types of responses. Principals working in schools that had already implemented a competency-based system (and thus, grading reforms) were, overall, not interested in making use of a pass/fail system. Principals in traditional schools, on the other hand, were very interested in such a policy. A pass/fail system is a fail for our kids, and a fail for our school. It serves to remind us that we don’t have a reliable grading system. 
In a 2019 MultiBriefs Exclusive, I asked an ironic question: Do Grades Matter? My article was a follow up to a series of articles on grading reform released by ASCD where both teachers and researchers identified key considerations for assessments that "fairly gauge and report students' learning" and a model where the traditional A-F system is replaced by one that is a better indicator of student learning. Grading reform is not new, and this is not the first time I have written about it. As a principal in a nationally-recognized competency-based learning school, grading reform has been a big part of my work. In my 2018 Solution Tree book, Breaking With Tradition: The Shift to Competency-Based Learning in PLCs at Work, I outlined a grading system for the future that was based on the following principles:
  • Grading  is an exercise in judging student evidence against clearly defined criteria on well-defined rubrics.
  • Grades represent to what extent and to what degree a student has learned something.
  • Grades are not time-bound: Students learn at different rates and the amount of time it takes a student to learn something does not influence or impact a grade.
  • Grades are based on what students learn, not what they earn. They are not based on points that can be “taken away” due to student mis-behaviors (such as turning in an assignment “late”.
  • Achievement levels, and thus grading practices, must be fair, consistent, and calibrated across a school. Regardless of which educator is grading an assignment, the grade assigned should be consistent educator to educator. 
A  recent blog article from the Great Schools Partnership (GSP) entitled Learning Is What Matters in the End provides a comprehensive look at this topic and a call to action for educational leaders. “The pandemic sweeping our nation will produce grief and challenge for all of us. Those who were subject to the inequities of our systems are subjected all the more during such a crisis. Let’s make sure that our high school grading systems don’t increase these disparities—and indeed, fight back against them.” GSP closed the article by offering these four resources for those looking for more information:
  1. Grading and Reporting for Educational Equity, a tool from the Great Schools Partnership.
  2. Grading During Coronavirus: What’s the Right Call?, an article by Stephen Sawchuk for EdWeek.
  3. A New Normal: Assessment and Distance Learning a one-hour panel discussion by What’s the Story? Vermont (facilitated by Champlain Valley Union High School coaches Stan Williams and Emily Rinkema; panelists: Tom Guskey, Ken O’Connor, Rick Wormeli, Lee Ann Jung).
  4. How Schools Are Rethinking Online Grading, an article by Matt Zalaznick for District Administration

As we face an uncertain future in schools as a result of the pandemic, we have to do better for our students. The time for grading reform is now.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

My Speech to the NHS Inductees on Scholarship

By -
Image
Tonight, I will be speaking to you about scholarship, one of the four pillars of the National Honor Society. Scholarship is one of those words that we all can identify with, but it isn’t that easy to define. Dictionaries often define it to mean “academic achievement, learning; or the qualities of a scholar.” The qualities of a scholar --- well my ninth grade English teacher Mr. Tomallo never would have allowed me to use the word I was trying to define in the definition, so I have to dig deeper. What is a scholar? Again I turn to the dictionary, and I find the following: “A scholar is a learned person, someone who attends school or studies with a teacher.” I’m still not satisfied with this result. It seems the online dictionaries that Google has offered me are not helping me summarize what should be an easy-definable concept, scholarship. Perhaps I will need to research some examples of scholarship to help us better understand the concept.   In preparation for this speech...
Read more

Does Your School Facility Need a Makeover?

By -
Image
Does your school facility need a makeover? According to this 2012 report by the National Center for Education Statistics, 53% of American schools are due for such an upgrade. Upgrades can be done in ways to fit almost any school budget. The key for school principals is to stretch the financial resources they have to provide the biggest rate of return possible to enhance student learning and overall school culture.   At a recent visit to my child’s middle school, the principal took me on a tour of recent upgrades made to their front entrance lobby. The building, built quickly and cheaply in the 1970’s has long since reached the status of obsolete in our community, yet we as a voting community just aren’t ready to support a project to build a new middle school. Like so many other principals from coast to coast in this situation, the principal had to look for small ways to make facility upgrades that would have a big impact. The lobby project was this kind of a project. Much...
Read more

My Speech to the NHS Inductees on Character

By -
Image
Character is perhaps the most abstract of the four National Honor Society pillars, and that perhaps makes it the most difficult to quantify and speak about. Most of us would say that we know good character when we see it. We identify with examples of strong character. Consider this situation: Four friends from out of state are passing through Kingston on their way to a vacation in the White Mountains. Their names are Jerry, Elaine, George, and Kramer. Yes, for those of you who recognize this story I am talking about the 4 main characters from the television series Seinfeld and this is the famous “final episode.” They witness a robbery in broad daylight. The robber has his hand in his pocket, and the victim shouts that the man has a gun. As soon as the robber runs away, a Kingston policeman appears on the scene; but instead of pursuing the robber, he arrests Jerry, Elaine, George, and Kramer for having violated the "Good Samaritan" law. Since the four of them spent ...
Read more