Rethinking Failure
Earlier this month, The Washington Post’s Moriah Balingit and Donna St. George opened up a large debate by asking the question, is it becoming too hard to fail? Their article discussed how schools are shifting toward no-zero grading policies as a way to focus a student’s grade on what they know and are able to do rather than to use grades as a means to motivate or punish students for their academic behavior. Balingit and St. George highlighted large school districts like Virginia’s Fairfax County and Maryland’s Prince George’s County that have created policies to make 50 the lowest possible failing grade. In his book Fair Isn’t Always Equal: Grading and Assessing in the Differentiated Classroom , former Fairfax County teacher turned educational speaker and author Rick Wormeli offers this strategy as one way to level the playing field and make a failing grade carry an equal weight to any other grade in the 100 point grading scale. His argument is that in the current sc...